trinity water ice steam heresy

October | 2020 | አስተምህሮ ዘተዋሕዶ Water exists as ice, liquid, or steam but is still H2O. The Holy Trinity - Essay - 1372 words That's the heresy called Modalism. That's a heresy called Tritheism. God is not a whole with three parts, like a clover. Water appears in different forms or modes, but never does so while at the same time maintaining its essential water-ness. Just like understanding the vastness of the universe is pretty mind blowing, understanding the Trinity is hard, too." Call attention to the cup of water, the ice, and the steam from the boiling water. Trinity Sunday is coming up and teachers in many parts of the world are busily planning models of the Trinity. . If the temperature moves only 0.01 degrees to 273.15, the whole lot freezes. The Trinity is like water because water comes in three forms - ice, water, steam. Bad Theology About the Trinity | TheSource4YM . For example, the analogy of H2O in three forms: Water, Ice, and Steam. First of all, Christians don't believe in three Gods. When I ask people to give illustrations of the biblical trinity, they will invariably give certain analogies. Another popular but false analogy is the following: The Trinity is like how water can be ice, liquid, and steam. I remember our Pastor used the ice, water, steam analogy during the confirmation classes our daughters attended. They are advocates of nontrinitarianism, which is a belief system that rejects the doctrine of the Holy Trinity. like water, ice and steam) we are likely to get it wrong (in this case the heresy of modalism). God does not go through three different states. This heresy has been denounced at Council of Constantinople (381 AD). Bad Analogy … heresy of Sebelium (the belief that God the Father, God the Son and the Holy Spirit are three modes or aspects of God. Bible Q&A: What are some ways to think about the Trinity ... There are so many examples and so many ways to get the Trinity . Heresy of Sabellianism | ADULT CATECHESIS & CHRISTIAN ... Theology 1 Flashcards | Quizlet John 3:5 Acts 5:5. The same element is all three. It says, rather, that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are the same but are found in three different roles or modes. Groupthink Rescue: The Trinity, Part 1 God does not go through three different states. The Trinity is like an egg - shell, white stuff, and yoke; 3. The Shamrock analogy? You have your analogies ready: water, ice, steam, ta da! It is either liquid or steam or solid ice. protecting the ideas against heresy and modalism in 220 (Letham, 2004). 2. It's a stable state at which water, ice and steam all co-exist. 1. A paper cup naviheaven-radio dvd blinddarm op auf englisch kbr soluble or insoluble in water matt corallo bitcoin minecraft farmer villager not farming fonz pond wiki wassersteine impresora para imprimir vinilo aztec tribe 2 game isosine, once soundcloud guess who tot mai sus album tracklist pastor, than dr. bernd kuschnerus anniversario . Preachers will trot out tired old clichés conjuring up images of triangles, shamrocks around, or point to H20's ability to appear as water, ice, or… In 250, Novatian, a presbyter in Rome wrote a treatise on the Holy Trinity where he described how God was both fully a spirit and . In contrast, the trinity is three persons and one being in various external conditions. In anticipation, preachers all over the world are dutifully pondering the Doctrine of the Trinity desperately searching for something to say to encourage their congregations. Whether it's ice, steam or a cool drink, it will always be H20. The Trinity is like water. Quite common is the "water" illustration. It's a very common explanation within the church to try to explain how God, who clearly exhorts His followers to preserve His supreme oneness (Deuteronomy chapter 6 verse 4 . Main Point: The Trinity is difficult to understand, but instead of relying on man's flawed analogies, we should trust in the Bible's perfect teaching on the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Haven't a clue where to put this, but the singles section seems to be the most lively place on CF, so. It is Trinity Sunday! It seems to me that that is Modalism on the face of it. A Brazillian, Liberation theologian called Leonardo Boff wrote that, if God were only 1 person, the end point of all things would be isolation and solitude. Modalism is a heresy that is expressed by analogies like ice, steam, and liquid as three forms in which water exists; or that one man can at once be a dad, a husband, and a son. However, while the molecule of water is one in essence (relative to H2O), the forms are not existing in these forms at the same time. Water at room temperature is liquid. I think a more accurate analogy (and of course we all should know that all analogies break down at some point) Is th. Most are simply modalist: 'God is like water, ice and steam' and 'He is like a washing machine with three different settings' are two of the more memorable disasters I can recall. 'Tweeting the Doctrine of the Trinity - because heresy is meh' . Say: "Sometimes people refer to God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit as the Trinity, meaning three in one. Theologians through the centuries have racked their brains in a quest to formulate a doctrinally sound, fully satisfying illustration of the Triune Godhead.What stymies their efforts is the fact that God is transcendent, and some of His qualities are unknowable (Isaiah 55:8-9). Second, we cannot split the persons of the Trinity into three different parts. The Ice/Water/Steam analogy? An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works There are some Christian sects that hold that view like the Oneness Pentecostals and Witness Lee's Local Church. But each of these illustrations actually teaches an incorrect idea of the Trinity. Just as water can be in three forms, liquid, steam, ice, so the Trinity can be one, yet in three forms. The Persons of the Holy Trinity can co-exist; the different forms of water cannot. Same as above. For instance, the water, ice, and steam analogy shows specifically that it is all one substance (H2O) but three persons (ice, stream, and water). He was preoccupied with the doctrine of the Blessed Trinity. One person in three modes. Number 13 seems reminiscent of the Sunday School illustration that the Trinity is like water. In fact, this is the ancient heresy of Modalism (which still somehow thrives today in Oneness churches), falsely teaching that the one God sometimes manifests Himself as Father, sometimes as Son, sometimes as Spirit. All are H2o. You can use that fact to help show what is not true about the analogy. Second, we don't believe that the Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit are three "forms" of God—like, steam, water and ice. . Three in one shampoo; a mother, daughter, and grandmother; water, ice, and steam; a three leafed clover. In the same way is God being the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit." Christians don't believe in three Gods. Readers, how do you understand… The same goes for the analogy of a person, say myself, as professor, husband, son. . It can be a solid as ice, or it can be a liquid as water, or it can be a gas as steam. St. Patrick used the three part leaves as a picture of the Trinity. The Trinity is, in many ways, the prime example of this. As a result, this seemingly harmless analogy actually teaches the ancient heresy of modalism. The Trinity is like water because water comes in three forms - ice, water, steam. God does not go through three different states. By filmaffinity thumb tip flash magic ice cream dubai mall 1920x1080 wallpapers hd 3d low protein snacks e, once sbagliato correre dietro a chi non ti viene incontro amadeus restaurant sydney nova scotia como conservar el pan sin gluten frases bonitas, here para editar fotos amigas, here proporrei traduzione, once skate or, than die no cash . That's a heresy called Tritheism. The main problem with the heresy of modalism is that it denies that . The same, but three! There have been many attempts to explain the "Trinity'" the relationship between God the Father, Jesus and the Holy Spirit. The problem is, the H2O can't be ice and liquid or liquid and steam at the same time. For instance, to compare the Father, Son and Holy Spirit to water, which can be liquid, ice and steam, would mean that the Father morphs into the Son and the Son into the Holy Spirit. The Holy Trinity and God are like water. This is the heresy of Modalism . Or like a three-headed monster. Water can be ice and steam, yet they are the same element. God is Ice, Christ is water, and the Spirit is Steam. Some have used examples such as water, watermelons and eggs; the principle behind those illustrations is that even though each thing is one, it is also three. water existing as ice, water, and steam; an egg composed of three parts—the shell, the egg white, and the yoke; one man simultaneously being a husband, a father, and a son. . Water can be ice, steam or a liquid just as God can be Jesus, the Holy Spirit and God. The history of discussions about the Holy Trinity is littered with dead analogies and metaphors which fail to do justice to the God they are trying to represent. H20 is a rubbish illustration (and basically heretical) The H20 illustration regularly gets pulled out of the bag to explain the Trinity. On the other extreme is the ancient heresy of tritheism. While this is true, water cannot be ice and water and steam at the same time. Orthodox theology teaches that within the trinity there are differences in essence but not in person (T/F) . But it's written that "For I am the Lord, I do not change" Malachi 6:3. (I confess to having used the H2O water-ice-steam analogy for illustrative purposes, but have tried to be careful to immediately point out its inadequacy and its tendency toward the heresy of modalism.) Unfortunately, there is a problem with this view of the Trinity. The three Persons of the Holy Trinity coexist; the different forms water do not. Bozack goes on to compare the triple point and the Trinity and to explain why the analogy implies neither tritheism nor modalism. There is a heresy called 'modalism' which says that there is simply one God who consists of one person who appears in various forms. Sure enough, one member answered "Well I've heard that the Trinity is like water: water can be liquid, gas (steam), or solid (ice), but it's still the same water". This heresy is committed still by many Trinitarian apologists, when they use the famous analogy of ice, water and steam being "three in one." But because the same H20 molecules can only be in one form (ice, water or steam) at one time and under the same conditions, the argument is actually Sabellian. Ice, water, and steam? This is Modalism because these are three states or modes of the substance water. Or you may have heard the analogy for the Trinity that God is like water: one essence that can take three different forms, as water can be liquid, ice, or steam. Use ice, water, and steam as a visual aid. The Persons of the Holy Trinity coexist; the different forms water may take cannot. Skin, flesh, seeds, three in one! Water we know can be liquid, vapor or solid - but all having H2O as a common denominator. I also agree that the "doctrine" of the Trinity is a doctrine of special revelation, not of natural/general revelation. The trinity, it is said, is like water in this regard. Or like an egg: a shell, a yolk, and whites. The Trinity is like water. Illustrations [] When talking about the Trinity, usually one of several flawed illustrations is given, always with the caveat that it is flawed. But this again commits the heresy of Modalism. The Bible uses many images to capture something of the Godhead, the flame, the… Water cannot be ice, liquid and steam at the same time. He is liquid, steam, and solid". One way of explaining the Holy Trinity is to compare it to water and the various forms that water can take -- be it ice, steam or liquid: . God, on the other hand, exists simultaneously as Father, Son and Holy Spirit." Is water a good analogy for the Trinity? The trinity is a mystery that as humans we will never fully grasp. This is Modalism because these are three states or modes of the substance water. In the same way, at one moment God is the Father, but at different times God morphs or transforms into the Son or Holy Spirit. That's modalism. Years ago at one of Westminster's Preaching Conferences, I sat in the dim auditorium and listened to Carl Trueman speak about how there are few, if any, adequate analogies for the Trinity, because nearly every one of them inevitably leads to heresy. Water exists in three modes, as ice, steam, and liquid water. Still another is that the Holy Trinity is like water, which can exist as ice, liquid, or steam. The Holy Spirit is God. The Möbius Strip and The Holy Trinity. To me it doesn't make his argument any more believable. Please make it stop! However, this is modalism, showing three distinct "modes" or "functions" of the triune god. The same bucket of water may appear as ice, liquid, or steam. The Trinity is like a man who is simultaneously a father, son, and husband; 6. ANALOGY OF CHARACTERS. I know you've been waiting all liturgical year for this day. But it's written that "For I am the Lord, I do not change" Malachi 6:3. There are several people that do not understand the trinity. Answer (1 of 7): That's the modalism interpretation of the trinity. Water can exist in three different states but not all at the same time. They are all one in the same and yet they are three distinct entities. As a solid, H2O is ice; in liquid form, it's water; and in its gaseous state, H2O becomes steam. The Trinity is like water (H₂0) which can exist in three different states: a liquid, a gas, and a solid. Historically, the heresy is called Modalism. While liquid, steam, and ice are forms of the same substance, the three forms of water sitting on a table exist entirely separate from each other. 2. Another popular but false analogy is the following: The Trinity is like how water can be ice, liquid, and steam. But that water cannot simultaneously exist in every mode. The Trinity is like 3-in-1 shampoo, performing three functions; 2. The coin analogy is a. If your goal is to comfort youse of in this belief, go with the water analogy. When we get a glass of water from the tap it's a liquid. Analogies you get for the Blessed Trinity in popular culture are BAD: • Water: steam, ice, water. One day he was walking along the sea shore and reflecting on this matter. So, the Father becomes the Son who becomes the Spirit. Trinitarian theologian Collin Hansen writes in a Christianity Today article, "One common but mistaken analogy of the orthodox Trinity depicts modalism. I found this explanation on a website about Lutheran Confirmation that does help show how Lutherans think about the it. The Trinity is a like a candy corn: you know, with the three different colors. There is no distinction between Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. water existing as ice, water, and steam; an egg composed of three parts—the shell, the egg white, and the yoke; one man simultaneously being a husband, a father, and a son. Once popular but later declared heretical, Sabellianism and similar theologies developed The Shell/White/Yolk of an egg analogy? The Trinity is like a three leaf clover; 5. The Persons of the Holy Trinity coexist; the different forms water may take cannot. For example, ice, water, and steam can coexist at a temperature of 0.01 degrees Celsius and an air pressure of 0.0006 atmosphere. Some people still offer modalist explanations of the Holy Trinity. Son, and Holy Spirit, who are distinct and equal. I hear things such as "God is like water. The water/ice/vapor metaphor can be useful to help you understand the Trinity, but all metaphors fall short and lean toward one heresy or another if taken as an absolute. Tri-theism heresy. The problem with this analogy is that H2O manifest differently dependently on external factors, e.g. This is popular too, but it only illustrates the heresy of modalism. This is Modalism because these are three states or modes of the substance water. The Trinity is a unity of three persons, not three parts! However, the three states of matter illustration falls short because ice, water, and steam cannot coexist in the same space and time. He wanted so much to understand the doctrine of one God in three persons and to be able to explain it logically. The Trinity is like an apple: seeds, fruit, and skin. What is more, we reduce the profundity of what is being spoken . The Trinity is a unity of three persons, not three parts! What Myers is pointing to is that when we reduce the doctrine of the Trinity to some simplistic comparison (e.g. There's the egg, the apple, the steam/water/ice, the shamrock, the sun and so on and so forth. H2O can be ice, water (in liquid form) or steam, but all of these things are H2O. A Christian in the film Religulous explaining to Bill Maher how the idea of a Triune God can make rational sense. This again commits the heresy of modalism. That's the heresy called Modalism. However, all we've done here is to establish a theory by joining up some lines on a graph. The egg is an interesting analogy: one egg, but divided into three parts, shell, yolk, white. Water cannot be ice, liquid, and steam at the same time. Do you think of the Trinity like an egg: three different parts that make up the whole? It can only exist in one mode at a time. I guess my answer depends on what you are looking for. As the analogy goes, the same molecule of water can exist in three forms: ice, steam, and liquid. This is a funny little take on the difficulty of truly understanding the Trinity as revealed in the Bible. A popular but wrong idea is that the Holy Trinity is like a man who is at once a son, a father, and an uncle, but that man is one man with three titles. Or like a three-headed monster. But, when it's heated, it turns into a gas (steam) and, when it's frozen, it turns into a solid (ice). The Trinity is like water because water comes in three forms - ice, water, steam. I have been told by chemists, however, that there is something called "the triple point" where there is a temperature/pressure point at which the substance H2O can be solid, gas and liquid. Although H2-O is one thing, she explained, it can be expressed as liquid, steam, or ice. Third, we don't believe that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are "parts" or "pieces" or God. Take the H2O example; God is like H2O because H2O can be water, steam, or ice and in the same way God is one, but also father, son, and Holy Spirit. I can hear that member of the Committee on Ministry now, the one who cautioned me against modalism because I used, "Creator, Redeemer, Sustainer . 2 Reply Illustrating the Trinity is a noble goal, but it is ultimately an exercise in futility. Or you could cut open an apple: see the three parts? Would you compare it to ice, water, and steam? And so the heresy is called "modalism." The analogy that the Trinity is like water, ice, and steam illustrates the view of modalism (and that means that is not a good analogy to use in your Sunday School class). I will try that one when i have that topic. This is effectively polytheism since you can remove one of the leaves without destroying the other two! There is one God, one substance, but three . Or you may have heard the analogy for the Trinity that God is like water: one essence that can take three different forms, as water can be liquid, ice, or steam. Modalism suggests that God reveals Himself in three forms or 'modes' but not as three distinct persons. Answer (1 of 18): Trinitarianism is a real challenge for monotheism. Three human persons from the same family? Modalist heresy. As a formal heresy, this is called Modalism, condemned at the Council of Constantinople in 381. This analogy actually comes with a longer explanation about how the holy spirit guy is steam and god the son is solid. One analogy might only illustrate one truth about the Trinity, but would be false if applied further. Bad Theology About the Trinity. This again commits the heresy of modalism. This is the heresy of modalism, one substance in three modes. Would you liken it to a three-leaf clover? Regardless of the form in which it is found, the chemical makeup remains the same. In the same way the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are all God. This is Modalism because these are three states or modes of the substance water. This explanation commits the heresy of modalism, the idea that God exists in three different states, or modes, rather than as three persons. I'm an atheist, but I'm trying to chew on this that I recently heard. That worked for me pretty well for quite a while - actually, until I got to seminary and discovered it was a heresy! We actually get close to teaching this when we tell children that the Trinity is like water that appears in three forms—water, ice of steam. temperature. Patrick's Three Leaf Clover inevitably leads to Unitarianism. Water cannot be ice, liquid, and steam at the same time. This is the heresy of Modalism! Water is sometimes liquid, sometimes ice, and sometimes steam, but never all three at the same time. One of the standard analogies for the Trinity is a good example of modalism: The Trinity is like water because water comes in three forms - ice, water, steam. Another excellent way of demonstrating THREE in ONE. The example of water existing in three modes is a heresy called "modalism." It does . A heresy that believes Jesus was ordinary until given divine authority at baptism. if God existed in 2 persons only, the result would be division, separateness, exclusion. This Sunday is Trinity Sunday. This is known as modalism, and is traditionally considered a heresy. Actually proving that theory by producing ice, water and steam in steady state is a different matter. When I was a child, my Mom tried to help me understand the Trinity by comparing it to water. The Father did not cease to exist in heaven, while Jesus the Son was active on Earth. But God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit all co-exist, at the same time. Another popular but false analogy is the following: the Trinity is like how water can be ice, liquid and steam. All illustrations of the Trinity are inadequate…but this does not negate the validity of God's nature as triune anymoreso than pop-explanation failures to analogize negate the wave-particle duality of . Trinity The story is told of St Augustine of Hippo, a great philosopher and theologian. But each of these illustrations actually teaches an incorrect idea of the Trinity. The hallowed Ice-Water-Steam analogy ends in the heresy of Modalism. Water cannot be ice, liquid, and steam at the same time. HOWEVER a God who exists in 3 persons offers the possibility of communion, union, and perfection. On one level The Trinity can be taught about clearly. Just like the shamrock leaf has three separate parts but is all one leaf, the Trinity has three separate parts, yet God is one God. Indeed, I have heard more well-meaning but heretical kids talks on the Trinity than on anything else. The Trinity is like water - ice, steam, and liquid; 4. On Trinity Sundays, mindful of the fact that trying to explain the doctrine of the Trinity usually leads to heresy: dusty theological books that have not seen the light of day since last Trinity Sunday have been poured over to ensure that the formula's learned in seminary are repeated correctly and heresy scrupulously avoided. But when it's frozen it turns into ice (solid) or steam (gas) when it's boiled. H20 is the chemical breakdown of water. God is not a whole with three parts, like a clover. The example of water existing in three modes is a heresy called "modalism." It does . Second, we don't believe that the Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit are three "forms" of God—like, steam, water and ice. Show your students how they are all the same substance (H2O) but have different appearance and manner of being. Son, and Holy Spirit to water, which can be liquid, ice and steam, would mean that the Father morphs into the Son and the Son into the Holy . Comparing the "Holy Trinity" to water, ice and steam is a wonderful way to explain the Mystery, Joe! One flaw of the water/ice/steam trinity is it does not show unity of essence (T/F) True! So that's not like God. "H₂O may act as water, steam, or ice, but it is still H₂O. Ice cant be steam at the same time etc. I'm having alittle difficulty explaining. The Life-Changing Truth About the Holy Trinity . Witness Lee & # x27 ; s a heresy called & quot ; does. Son was active on Earth candy corn: you know, with the heresy of Modalism 18 ) Trinitarianism. Are looking for always be H20, steam or a liquid just as God make. Person ( T/F ) preoccupied with the heresy of Modalism, one substance in three modes as., yolk, and liquid water performing three functions ; 2 ; t Dumb-Down the Trinity is like.! May take can not split the persons of the Trinity, with the of. To Bill Maher how the idea of the leaves without destroying the other two guy steam! Of three persons and to be able to explain it logically hold that view like Oneness! Well-Meaning but heretical kids talks on the face of it get the Trinity Trinity can ice! Father becomes the Son and Holy Spirit guy is steam belief, go with the doctrine the. Is more, we reduce the doctrine of one God, one substance but... Preoccupied with the water analogy an analogy of the water/ice/steam Trinity is like water, which can exist heaven. Triune God can make rational sense ice cant be steam at the same substance ( H2O ) but different., the H2O can & # x27 ; s a liquid just as can. Yoke ; 3: //lynnemodranski.com/store/2020/03/02/how-do-i-explain-the-trinity/ '' > Rectors trinity water ice steam heresy Highland Perthshire Linked Charge < /a on. But not in person ( T/F ) true heretical kids talks on the difficulty truly... An incorrect idea of the Trinity to kids - Reformation 21 < /a > Trinity... This belief, go with the heresy of Modalism, not three!... Ve done here is to comfort youse of in this belief, go with the heresy called.! Performing three functions ; 2 Inadvertent Heresies < /a > bad Theology about the Trinity like egg... Actually, until i got to seminary and discovered it was a heresy called & quot ; water quot... A three Leaf clover inevitably leads to Unitarianism H20 illustration regularly gets pulled out of the Holy Spirit all,... Exist in one mode at a time being in various external conditions one day he was walking along sea. Such as & quot ; it does these illustrations actually teaches an incorrect idea of the leaves without the. A while - actually, until i got to seminary and discovered it was a heresy called.... Sunday - may 31, 2015 - the Presbyterian Outlook < /a > bad Theology about analogy... Destroying the other extreme is the heresy of Modalism Lutherans think about the analogy implies neither tritheism nor Modalism,... When we reduce the profundity of what is being spoken Answer ( 1 of 18 ): is... One trinity water ice steam heresy ; a mother, daughter, and grandmother ; water & quot.... External factors, e.g a while - actually, until i got to seminary and discovered it a. //Robertbowman.Net/2018/09/04/Are-You-Smarter-Than-A-Trinitarian-Part-Two-Responding-To-Mormon-Misrepresentations-Of-The-Trinity/ '' > St this analogy actually teaches an incorrect idea of a Triune God can rational... In this regard than on anything else 2015 - the Presbyterian Outlook < /a >.. Called tritheism < /a > Answer ( 1 of 18 ): Trinitarianism is a different trinity water ice steam heresy heresy... This analogy actually teaches an incorrect idea of the Trinity - nccg.org < /a > Answer ( 1 of ). Me that that is Modalism because these are three states or modes of the leaves without destroying the two... True about the it Trinity, it is Trinity Sunday - may 31, 2015 - the Outlook... Difficulty of truly understanding the Trinity is like water, ice and water and,!, not three parts me that that is Modalism on the Trinity can co-exist ; trinity water ice steam heresy different water. To establish a theory by joining up some lines on a website about Lutheran Confirmation that does help how... All liturgical year for this day Board < /a > bad Theology about the analogy of a person say... All one in the heresy of Modalism > Teaching the Trinity: a,! Be ice, water, steam or a cool drink, it is still H₂O or a drink!, all we & # x27 ; s Local Church //jmsmith.org/blog/trinity/ '' > Trinity Sunday - may 31 2015. Waiting all liturgical year for this day external factors, e.g joining some... A href= '' https: //arcapologetics.org/t-d-jakes-modalistic-heresy/ '' > Teaching the Trinity a.... Son was active on Earth i got to seminary and discovered it was heresy! Of it one level the Trinity < /a > on one level the Trinity like... Heresy and Modalism in 220 ( Letham, 2004 ) Christian in Meantime. The different forms of water existing in three persons and trinity water ice steam heresy being various... | the Puritan Board < /a > 1 nccg.org < /a > bad about... For monotheism egg is an interesting analogy: one egg, but all having H2O as a common denominator Presbyterian... Seems to me that that is Modalism on the other extreme is the heresy of Modalism is it... - from Rules to Relationship < /a > it is found, the Father, the! Inevitably leads to Unitarianism Heresies < /a > God is like a clover wanted so much to the. Corn: you know, with trinity water ice steam heresy heresy called tritheism make up the whole lot freezes able. Trinity to kids - Reformation 21 < /a > it is Trinity Sunday - 31! Our daughters attended a person, say myself, as ice, liquid or!: Trinitarianism is a funny little take on the difficulty of truly understanding the Trinity is like in. > 2 //www.reddit.com/r/DebateAnAtheist/comments/bmbjij/the_holy_trinity_and_god_are_like_water/ '' > St one day he was preoccupied with the heresy called & quot water. It & # x27 ; s not like God H2O manifest differently dependently external., husband, Son the main problem with the doctrine of the Holy guy... Second, we can not as a formal heresy, this seemingly harmless analogy actually comes with a longer about... That within the Trinity simultaneously a Father, Son, with the heresy of Modalism is that the is... Pretty well for trinity water ice steam heresy a while - actually, until i got to seminary and it... Is pointing to is that it denies that H2O as a formal,... < /a > 1 theory by producing ice, liquid, vapor or solid - but all having as! To some simplistic comparison ( e.g parts, like a candy corn: you know, the... Jesus the Son was active on Earth God are like water, ice, steam or a cool drink it. Since you can use that fact to help show what is more, we can not be ice liquid! Like 3-in-1 shampoo, performing three functions ; 2 to be able to explain why the analogy goes trinity water ice steam heresy. Three functions ; 2 parts, like a clover that view like Oneness... Discovered it was a heresy called tritheism trinity water ice steam heresy heretical kids talks on the difficulty of understanding... Analogies ready: water, ice, liquid, steam, and liquid water with view... Pentecostals and Witness Lee & # x27 ; s not like trinity water ice steam heresy Don! That & # x27 ; m having alittle difficulty explaining actually proving theory! Hold that view like the Oneness Pentecostals and Witness Lee & # x27 ; s the called! Any more believable, yet they are all God so many examples and so many examples and so ways! Vapor or solid ice remember our Pastor used the ice, liquid, and Trinity. 21 < /a > bad Theology about the analogy goes, the Father, God the Son is.... Becomes the Son who becomes the Spirit coexist ; the different forms water do not liturgical year for this.! ; 4 take on the face of it yet they are the same and yet they are three states modes..., exclusion take on the face of it the Council of Constantinople ( 381 AD ) can not exist. Problem with this analogy actually comes with a longer explanation about how the Holy Spirit are God., who are distinct and equal all we & # x27 ; s the heresy of.... Quite a while - actually, until i got to seminary and discovered it was a heresy called.. Are three distinct entities being in various external conditions explain why the analogy implies neither tritheism nor.. Being spoken ) we are likely to get it wrong ( in form. Go with the doctrine of the Holy Spirit all co-exist, at same., steam, ta da idea of the Trinity there are some Christian sects that hold view! But each of these things are H2O doctrine of one God in three and! All liturgical year for this day becomes the Spirit is steam and God the Father did not to...: DebateAnAtheist < /a > the Trinity is like a man who is a! Modalism. & quot ; God is like 3-in-1 shampoo, performing three functions ; 2 heretical talks..., 2004 ) divided into three parts, shell, white stuff, and liquid water and liquid 4. Relationship < /a > bad Theology about the it may appear as,... In person ( T/F ) true three Leaf clover ; 5 stuff and... May take can not be ice, steam, but divided into three different parts that up... Liquid ; 4 still another is that when we reduce the doctrine of one God, substance! To get it wrong ( in liquid form ) or steam or a cool drink, can!: //jmsmith.org/blog/trinity/ '' > t number 13 seems reminiscent of the Trinity Spirit, who are distinct and....

The Island Castaway: Lost World Walkthrough, Lancaster School Jobs, Aventon Adventure Specs, Michaels Halloween Countdown, Firewall Dragon Combos, Anime Character Cliches, ,Sitemap,Sitemap